We often imagine memory as a high-definition recording—a faithful mental archive we can play back whenever we want. But the truth is more complicated, even unsettling. Memory isn’t fixed; it’s elastic, colored by moods, emotions, and current beliefs. Each time we recall an event, we subtly rewrite it. We exaggerate certain details, forget others, and reshape our past to fit the story we’re telling ourselves today.
When Memory Fades, Identity Shifts
Our memories don’t just store information—they define who we are. The stories we remember about ourselves help build our identity. Someone who identifies as a nonconformist, for instance, will recall moments of rebellion more vividly than times of conformity. But what happens when memory itself fades?
Neurologist Oliver Sacks told a moving story about a man named Jimmie G., known as “The Lost Mariner,” who suffered from Korsakoff syndrome—a condition linked to vitamin B1 deficiency and heavy drinking. Jimmie could recall almost nothing after his teenage years. He lived adrift in time, unable to connect with others or sustain a sense of self. Without memory, his identity had dissolved. It’s a reminder that to remember is, in many ways, to exist.
The Brain’s Tricks: Why We Misremember
If memory is so unreliable, can we ever trust our own recollections? The distortions that plague memory aren’t flaws—they’re features evolved to help us survive. Our ancestors needed quick thinking and fast associations to adapt, which came at the cost of perfect accuracy.
Still, some people are more resistant to false memories. High cognitive ability—skills like reasoning and abstract thinking—tends to reduce susceptibility to misinformation. So does cognitive flexibility, or the ability to shift perspectives when necessary. Interestingly, being cautious or even a little pessimistic can also help; people in bad moods tend to have sharper recall because they’re less overconfident and more alert to errors.
Nature, Nurture, and the Mind’s Architecture
Our ability to think clearly isn’t purely learned or purely genetic—it’s both. Genes, scientists have found, explain roughly half the differences between individuals in traits such as motivation and cognition. But this doesn’t mean your genes control half of your motivation; it simply means half the variation seen across people can be linked to genetics, while the rest depends on environment, upbringing, and experience.
Genes may set a baseline, but experience writes the story. A great teacher, a supportive home, or a challenging environment can reshape how we think. And even people with the same IQ or working memory can differ dramatically in creativity, flexibility, and critical thinking—all key components of decision-making and problem-solving.
The Role of Personality in Thinking
Much of how we think also depends on our personality. Psychologists often describe personality using the “Big Five” model:
- Extraversion: Sociability and energy from interaction.
- Agreeableness: Compassion and cooperativeness.
- Conscientiousness: Discipline and a sense of duty.
- Emotional Stability: Resistance to anxiety and mood swings.
- Openness to Experience: Curiosity and appreciation for new ideas.
Each trait shapes our thinking style. Emotional instability, for instance, can make one more pessimistic. High extraversion encourages social motivation but can bias toward pleasing others. Conscientious people analyze carefully but may become rigid. Openness fosters creativity and mental flexibility—a key trait for good reasoning.
Changing Minds Through Time
Personality, far from being fixed, evolves over a lifetime. Between our twenties and forties, we tend to become more stable, responsible, and sociable—traits that support careers and relationships. After sixty, we might grow less open to novelty as daily challenges decrease, but conscientiousness often continues to strengthen. Even situational context can momentarily shift who we are: more assertive at work, more reflective at home.
These subtle transformations suggest that identity and memory are in constant dialogue—each shaping, editing, and reinforcing the other.
Remembering to Think
The human mind, with all its biases and fragilities, is both a storyteller and a survivor. We can’t control how our memory rewrites the past, but we can stay alert to its distortions. The best safeguard may not be trying to be right all the time, but staying curious, flexible, and open to correction. In doing so, we honor both the fallibility and the brilliance of our imperfect minds.
Source : Are You Thinking Clearly?: 29 reasons you aren’t, and what to do about it by Matt Warren, Miriam Frankel
Goodreads : https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/61464581-are-you-thinking-clearly
Read the Previous Article in the Series :
Thinking Beyond Science 
Leave a comment